Free shipping on all UK orders

Worldwide shipping available

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Bra fit problems solved: Elomi, Freya and Fantasie bras, with fitting advice from Poinsettia Style

Bra Fit Problems Solved: Why Your Bra Is Misbehaving (and How to Fix It)

Bands that creep up your back, straps that slide off at the worst moment, cups that gape like they're waiting for someone else's boobs to arrive. We've all been there. The good news is that most bra niggles are your bra quietly telling you something about its size, and once you know the signs, they're easy to read.

With over 20 years of bra fitting experience, and helping customers since 2012, these are the fit problems we hear about most. The advice below comes straight from our bra fitting specialists. If any of this sounds familiar, you're in very good company.

Diagram of a bra showing where common fit problems happen: band riding up, red marks from the band, straps digging in or falling down, gaping cups, spilling over the top, bulge under the arm, underwire digging in at the sides, and the centre front not sitting flat, with a quick fix for each.

Why does my bra band keep riding up my back?

Short answer: your band is too big.

If your band is slowly inching its way up your back (the bra band boogie, as we like to call it), the back size is too big. When the band rides up at the back, your bust drops at the front, which is the opposite of what anyone wants.

Here's why it matters so much: the band does most of the work. A well-fitting underband gives you the support, not the straps. It should sit firmly and level all the way round, parallel to the ground, and stay put whether your arms are up or by your side.

A couple of quick checks:

  • You should be able to fit two fingers under the band, but not pull it far away from your body.
  • If you can pull it more than an inch from your back, it's time to size down.

Good fit checklist: the band sits firmly and level all the way round, a new bra fits snugly on the loosest hook, straps are comfortable and not digging in, cups sit smoothly without gaping, breasts sit fully inside the cups, the underwire rests on your ribcage behind your breast tissue, and the centre front sits flat against your chest bone.

Why does my bra band feel too tight or leave red marks?

Short answer: loosen it, or try a bigger back size.

Snug is good. Can't-breathe is not. If your band leaves painful red marks, it's too tight. If the underband is digging in, try loosening the band or going up a back size. A larger band size will feel more comfortable if your bra is too tight around the ribs.

Which hook should my new bra fit on?

Short answer: the loosest one.

A new bra should fit snugly on the loosest hook. Bands stretch with wear, and the tighter hooks are there so you can take it in as it does. If you can fasten a brand-new bra on the second or third hook, it's probably too big and you should try a band size down. When the band no longer feels snug even on the tightest hook, it's time for a new bra.

Why do my bra straps dig into my shoulders?

Short answer: they're too tight, and they're probably doing the band's job.

You know the feeling: off comes the bra at the end of the day and your shoulders say THANK YOU. Straps should feel comfortable and not dig in. If they're digging in or leaving a mark, they're too tight and need loosening.

Tightening your straps won't really give you more support, because that comes from the band. If you feel you need to hoick them up for support, your band may be too big. As a guide, you should be able to slide two flat fingers under each strap.

Why do my bra straps keep falling down?

Short answer: tighten them, and if that doesn't fix it, check your size.

Straps shouldn't be too tight or too loose. If they're falling off your shoulders, they need tightening, and if more than two fingers fit under a strap, it's too loose. Straps that keep falling down can also be a sign you're wearing the wrong size, so if adjusting doesn't sort it, it's worth checking your fit.

Why are my cups gaping or wrinkly at the top?

Short answer: your cup is likely too big.

A well-fitting cup sits smoothly without sagging or wrinkling. If your bust is fully enclosed but there's loose fabric, wrinkles or creases, try going down a cup size. Sometimes baggy cups mean a different style would suit your shape better, so our Bra Style Guide is a good next stop.

Why am I spilling over the top of my cups? (Hello, double boob)

Short answer: your cup is too small, so go up.

Double boob, quad-boob, the dreaded bulge. Whatever you call it, it's a sure sign your cups are too small. Your breasts should sit fully inside the cups with no spillage, and there should be no bulge or squashing under the arm.

Before you size up, make sure you're putting your bra on properly. Here's the "Swoop and Scoop" method:

  1. Lean forward from the waist and let your breasts drop into the cups.
  2. Swoop: with the opposite hand, gently bring the breast tissue forward from the back towards your cleavage.
  3. Scoop: lift the tissue in front of and on top of the underwire into the cup.
  4. Smooth any "fluffing" on top of the cups and between the breasts back into place with two fingers.

How to do the Swoop and Scoop in four steps: lean forward so your breasts drop into the cups, swoop the breast tissue forward from the back towards your cleavage, scoop the tissue above the underwire into the cup, then smooth any fluffing back into place with two fingers.

Still overflowing? The cup is too small. Don't be afraid to go up in the cup, even several cup sizes if necessary.

Is that armpit fat, or is it actually boob?

Short answer: it's often breast tissue that belongs in your cup.

Breast tissue extends towards your underarm, and your cups should hold all of it, including that bit at the side. What looks like armpit fat is often breast tissue that's wandered off and needs scooping back into the front of your bra. Popping it back where it belongs may mean going up a cup size or two, but the results can be epic.

If you'd like extra shaping at the side, a side support bra has a supportive side panel that gently brings the bust forward and towards the centre. The Fantasie Fusion Full Cup Side Support Bra in Red Framboise.

Why does my underwire dig in at the sides or sit on my boob?

Short answer: your cups are usually too small.

The underwire should sit behind your breast tissue, resting on your ribcage, not on top of your boob. If the wire sits away from your chest or digs in at the sides, the cups are too small and you'll need to go up a cup size. Uncomfortable under the arms? That usually means your cup is too small too. Some brands make styles with a wider underwire, which are ideal for a fuller bust.

Why doesn't the centre of my bra sit flat?

Short answer: if it's gapping, go up a cup. If it's digging in, try a bigger back.

The centre front (the bit where your cups join, also called the centre gore) should sit flat and firmly against your chest bone without digging in. If it sits away from your chest, your cups are probably too small, so try a larger cup size. If it digs in and feels uncomfortable, you may need to go up a back size.

How do I measure my bra size, and should I add 4 inches?

Short answer: measure snugly, and please don't add 4 inches.

Measure snugly around your ribcage, just under your bust, for your band, then loosely around the fullest part of your bust for your cup. Each brand's size chart is on its product pages, and our Size Charts help if you know your size in another country.

Adding 4 inches to your underbust measurement is the biggest mistake we see. It's a hangover from the days when bra fabrics didn't have the stretch they have now, and modern bras simply don't need it.

How often should I check my bra size?

Short answer: every six months.

We recommend checking your size every six months. Your size can change with weight, age, pregnancy, breastfeeding and menopause. Expecting? Our maternity and nursing bra fitting guide explains how your size can change.

Check your bra size every six months, as your size can change with weight, age, pregnancy, breastfeeding and menopause. Measure snugly around your ribcage just under your bust for your band, and loosely around the fullest part of your bust for your cup. Don't add 4 inches.

Still not sure? Ask us

We specialise in D+ cups and fuller busts, with back sizes from 28 to 46 and beyond and cups up to KK, depending on the style. Browse Elomi, Freya and Fantasie, or start with full cup, balcony and plunge bras.

Got a fit question we haven't covered? Email sales@poinsettiastyle.co.uk and our bra fitting specialists will reply within 1 working day, Monday to Friday.

Kind regards,
the Poinsettia Style team 💜

Previous post

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published